Good morning,

The reason I’m excited about crypto is its potential to improve individual freedoms and access. But the design of crypto networks are constrained by the tools available to them. Identity verification is one of those missing tools, and without it, many important mechanisms are impossible to design. This is the subject of this week’s update, and I suspect many more in the future.

On to the update.


Shapeshift, a service that let users exchange cryptocurrencies without revealing their identity, recently announced mandatory user accounts.

To some who have followed our history, it may seem a curious development; ShapeShift is known as “the exchange without accounts,” a model we pioneered in order to reduce friction and protect customers. Membership is account-based, so why are we departing from that lineage?

[…]

3) The practice of requiring customers to hand over personal private information is one we’ve struggled with since inception. To the extent that digital asset technology remains a legal grey area, we need to be prudent and thoughtful in our approach as we navigate the regulatory environment.

Unsurprisingly, the community reacted poorly to the news, with some flinging ad hominem attacks at the founder, Erik Vorhees1.

Why the strong reaction? A system that verifies the identities of its users places the power back in the hands of the legacy financial system. Now, Shapeshift is able to comply with authoritarian requests to deny service to an individual, or reveal the identity of a user. For many–particularly those that lean towards crypto anarchy–such a requirement is a non-starter.

This got me thinking about identity for crypto use-cases.

Use cases for identity

In some cases, like an exchange, you don’t need to be able to verify the identity of users, but it can be useful. Any exchange with meaningful volume needs market makers, and market makers tend to be institutional investors that are regulated to some extent. To attract those market makers and comply with regulations, the exchange would need not only verifiable identity, but KYC (“Know Your Customer”) verification of state issued documents (like a passport).

Already a member? Read the full update here

Become a member to get posts like this

Support the site and get members-only benefits

Subscribe for $100 a year

or subscribe monthly for $10 a month


Members receive a members-only analysis each week that is timely and substantial. I've been asked to be more opinionated and responsive to current events, so I'll try to do that in this more private forum. If you want my critical take on what matters in the industry, you might enjoy these analyses.

Over time, I'd love to develop more benefits like transcripts of podcasts (maybe host my own), a members-only discussion forum, AMAs with industry leaders, and more.

Thank you. I hope you'll stick around.

–Tony

If you aren’t already familiar with my work, I write long-form analyses on building and investing in crypto, and the impact of crypto on society.

My readers include investors at Union Square Ventures, a16z, Village Global, Multicoin Capital, Scalar Capital, and Polychain and builders of Bitcoin, Ethereum, Zcash, EOS, Tezos, 0x, and Coinbase.

Some awfully nice things people have said:

Tony’s blog is one of the best hidden gems in crypto. The content is regularly some of the most insightful out there. I read every post with a fine toothed comb.

–Kyle Samani, Cofounder and Managing Partner, Multicoin Capital

Tony is one of the most insightful and independent writers in the space. His newsletter consistently provides original perspectives on crypto/blockchain fundamentals that inspire you to think more critically.

–Soona Amhaz, Cofounder and CEO, Token Daily

If you read one person’s writing in the space, make it Tony’s. Tony breaks down complicated crypto concepts and economic theories in ways that educate both the beginner and expert alike.

–Erik Torenberg, Cofounder and Partner, Village Global

Member updates

October 16, 2018

USDT may or may not unwind, but its usefulness is at risk

October 9, 2018

The awkward Sia fork

October 3, 2018

Pixelmaster, FOMO3D and the predictable decline of greater fools games